Comparing Features
The Alumacraft Trophy and Competitor, both redesigned for 2025, are classified as “Fish & Sport” models, indicating their suitability for both fishing and recreational activities. They share a range of features, necessitating a close comparison for discerning the optimal choice.
Shared Features:
- 2XB Hull: This exclusive Alumacraft construction, employed in both models, uses a double-plated hull with larger aircraft-grade rivets and a seamless one-piece bottom. This design ensures a smooth, quiet, and dry ride, even in rough water conditions.
- Bow Control Center: A new addition to both models, the bow control center offers a dedicated space for mounting a 12″ graph, holders for tools and cell phones (with a USB charging port), and a well for the trolling motor foot pedal.
- Rotax S and MAX Deck Compatibility: Both the Trophy and Competitor can be fitted with the optional Rotax S outboard engine. This integrated engine maximises usable space on the boat and allows for the installation of the MAX Deck, which provides an additional 25 sq ft of space.
- X-Pods: These transom extensions, standard on both models, wrap around the engine, adding 16″ of space, in-floor storage, improved access to the water at the stern, and increased buoyancy8.
- Redesigned Captain’s Helm: Both models benefit from a redesigned helm featuring improved integration for switching and electronics. The use of injection-moulded plastic enhances the fit and finish. Standard features include a 7″ Garmin digital display, NMEA network, and space for two optional 12″ graphs.
Distinguishing Features:
- Target User: The Trophy is specifically marketed as “the ultimate aluminium fishing boat“, targeting dedicated anglers. In contrast, the Competitor is presented as a “blank canvas“, allowing anglers to customise the boat with features and technology tailored to their specific fishing style.
- Storage: The Trophy boasts “full height cockpit storage” with integrated tackle tray storage, designed to accommodate a serious angler’s gear. The Competitor features “stepped cockpit storage“, which allows anglers to kneel on for better water access.
Making the Choice:
- Trophy: Opt for the Trophy if a ready-to-fish experience with ample, angler-focused storage is paramount. It’s ideal for those prioritising fishing time and success.
- Competitor: If customisation is key and you prefer tailoring your boat to your unique fishing style, the Competitor offers greater flexibility.
Pricing
Alumacraft Trophy and Competitor list very similar starting prices for each model.
- Alumacraft Trophy: Starting at $51,962
- Alumacraft Competitor: Starting at $40,687
Remember that these are just the starting prices, and the final cost will depend on the length of the boat, the features and customisations you choose, and whether you choose the traditional outboard engine or the Rotax S with the optional MAX deck. Transportation and preparation are also not included in the listed prices.
For a precise price comparison tailored to your desired specifications, I recommend utilising Alumacraft’s “Build & Price” tool on their website1…. This allows you to configure each model with your preferred options and see the resulting price difference. You can also “Request A Quote” from a dealer.
The ultimate decision hinges on your fishing style, desired customisation level, and budget. For an informed choice, explore the detailed specifications of each model on Alumacraft’s website.